Butter Board Recipe – Justine Doiron’s Viral Party Starter

How to Make a Butter Board – Justine Doiron’s Viral Party Starter

Butter Board Beginnings: From Viral Trend to Homestead Staple

The first time I saw someone make a butter board, I was halfway through kneading sourdough on a rainy October afternoon. I had flour on my hands, a stew simmering on the stove, and my phone propped up beside a jar of pickled beets. That’s when Justine Doiron’s video popped up—she was gently swirling softened butter across a wooden board and topping it with herbs, salt, citrus zest, even edible flowers. It wasn’t fussy or formal. It was inviting, generous, and completely unexpected. Something about the whole thing felt like home, but also new. I’d made plenty of compound butters before, using garlic from our garden or dill I’d strung to dry on the porch rafters—but I’d never thought to serve butter like this.

Why a Butter Board Belongs on Every Table

Since then, the butter board has become a go-to for gatherings at our place—especially in late summer, when the garden’s throwing more herbs and edible blooms than I can keep up with. There’s something so down-to-earth about laying out a board like that and letting everyone dig in with warm slices of crusty bread. It’s casual, sure, but it also feels special, like you’re sharing something handmade and heartfelt. And isn’t that what cooking’s really about? The butter board may have started as a social media moment, but it’s earned its spot on my table for good. I love pairing it alongside rustic appetizers like these charcuterie nachos for a spread that never fails to spark conversation. With the right toppings and a little love, it’s more than trendy—it’s timeless.

Table of Contents

Print

Butter Board Basics – The Essentials

The Guidelines You’ll Want to Follow

A butter board isn’t just about smearing butter on a slab and hoping for the best—it’s about balance, texture, and inviting presentation. Start with good butter. I mean really good butter—European-style if you can, with high fat content and no added salt. Let it soften until it spreads like peanut butter, not soup. That texture is key. I like to use a wooden board, but a slate or ceramic tray works just as well—just make sure it’s food-safe and easy to wipe clean.

Next comes the layout. Use the back of a spoon to swirl the butter across the board in even strokes, about a quarter inch thick. This gives it that signature visual flair. From there, season with flaky sea salt and a touch of citrus zest. These bring contrast and freshness. The final step? Toppings. You don’t need much—just two or three bold choices layered across the butter so each bite is different. A few toasted nuts, maybe some herbs, or even leftover roasted garlic from last night’s venison cowboy butter—if you’ve got it, use it.

The Essential Ingredients I Always Recommend

Over time, I’ve learned that certain ingredients just belong on a butter board. Flaky sea salt is non-negotiable. Its crunch and clean brininess bring the butter to life. Lemon or orange zest adds a fresh twist that cuts through the richness. And edible flowers? Well, they’re not just pretty—they lend a subtle herbaceousness and turn your board into something worth talking about.

Beyond the basics, fresh herbs are your best friend. Parsley, dill, mint, or even thyme—all offer something unique. I like to mix textures, too: try pairing soft fig slices with something crisp like radish or even a bit of onion for a kick. A drizzle of honey or chili oil gives each swipe of bread a little surprise. Think of your butter board as a blank canvas. What you spread, sprinkle, or scatter on top turns it into a story.

Building Flavor on Your Butter Board

Sweet & Bright: Honey Coriander and Figs + Mint

When you want your butter board to lean toward sweet, fragrant, and a little playful, these two topping combos deliver in the best way. Honey coriander is one of my all-time favorites—earthy coriander with warm cardamom and fresh mint layered over softened butter brings a depth that feels fancy but comes together in minutes. Add a few basil leaves for brightness and a swirl of golden honey for that glossy, sticky finish guests can’t resist.

Figs and mint, on the other hand, are for when you want something that feels rustic and slightly indulgent. Chopped fresh figs melt into the butter just enough to leave their syrupy trace, while a sprinkle of cinnamon and a drizzle of honey give it a cozy feel. Mint cuts through all that richness like a breeze on a hot day. I first tried this combo after making a batch of blood tongue sausage and needed something cooling to serve on the side—it turned out to be a crowd-pleasing balance.

Bold & Savory: Roasted Garlic + Rosemary and Cilantro + Chilies

If you’re more into savory boards (and I often am), these next pairings bring the kind of bold flavor that’ll have folks hovering by the platter. Roasted garlic is buttery in its own right—sweet, mellow, and perfect for layering over actual butter. Add rosemary sprigs toasted just enough to make your kitchen smell like a wood-fired oven, and you’ve got something both comforting and striking. Crack a little black pepper over the top and you’re golden.

Then there’s cilantro and chilies. This combo wakes up the whole board with fresh green herbs and the smoky depth of chili d’arbol oil. The heat doesn’t overpower—it builds gently, especially when cut with slivered red onion and bright parsley. It’s the kind of topping that surprises people—in a good way. On a crisp slice of sourdough, with butter soft enough to scoop, it’s proof that a butter board doesn’t have to be dainty to be delicious.

How to Make a Butter Board

What You’ll Need – Equipment and Ingredients

Putting together a butter board doesn’t take fancy tools—just a few kitchen staples and a little intention. You’ll need a solid board or platter to start with. Wood works beautifully, but slate or ceramic adds a clean, modern look. Just make sure it’s food-safe and big enough to hold your butter and toppings without crowding.

Here’s what you’ll want on hand:

• 2 sticks of high-quality unsalted butter, softened
• Flaky sea salt
• Zest from one lemon
• Edible dried flowers (optional, but striking)
• Your choice of toppings (like roasted garlic, fresh mint, figs, or chili oil)
• Crusty bread—sourdough or hearty whole grain is best

Having a small butter knife or spoon helps you swirl the butter in a visually appealing way. For folks who enjoy pairing flavors with meats or rich mains, this board goes beautifully alongside something like wild turkey recipes or a rustic soup.

How to Put It Together (Instructions + Pro Tips)

1. Soften the butter fully. Let it sit out until it’s easily spreadable—think peanut butter consistency, not melting.
2. Spread the butter in swirls. Use the back of a spoon or spatula to sweep the butter across the board in waves or loops.
3. Season simply. Sprinkle with flaky salt and lemon zest. These brighten and balance the richness.
4. Add your toppings. Choose one or two combos (from the sweet or savory pairings above). Distribute evenly across the butter.
5. Finish with flourishes. A scattering of edible flowers or fresh herbs adds texture and color.
6. Serve with bread. Offer slices of crusty bread or baguette on the side, slightly warm if possible.

Pro tip: If prepping ahead, spread the butter and refrigerate the board for up to a few hours. Add fresh toppings just before serving to keep everything vibrant.

Frequently Asked Questions About Butter Boards

Conclusion

At the heart of the butter board trend is something timeless: sharing good food in a way that feels generous and grounded. Whether you’re swirling herbs into softened butter from your kitchen garden or adding figs and mint from the market, the result is something your guests won’t soon forget. You don’t need fancy gear or culinary training—just real ingredients, a bit of creativity, and a willingness to let folks gather close and break bread together.

So next time you’re hosting, skip the store-bought dips and bring out your own butter board. It’s rustic, it’s beautiful, and best of all—it tastes like something made by hand, with heart.

📌 Follow along or tag me here:
Facebook: Recipes NYC on Facebook
Pinterest: @Recipes_NYC on Pinterest

Medium: https://medium.com/@recipesnyc